Christmas Carol – Season 5, Ep 6

CHAMBLISS: It’s not mine to accept or reject, Dana. We only make recommendations to the judge. But at this point I’d advise against you becoming an adoptive parent. You’re a single woman who’s never been married or had a long-term relationship.




Season 5, Episode 6: “Christmas Carol”

Screen Shot 2016-01-03 at 4.00.12 PM


I watch The X-Files a lot, but even I have some priorities. There are some episodes that I’ll never rewatch because frankly, they’re a waste of my time. If it weren’t for the fact that I agreed to review every single episode of this show, I’d be perfectly content with never having to watch “Christmas Carol” and its follow-up episode, “Emily,” ever again.

No. Just no.

I think I’d only watched this episode straight through once before my most recent rewatch for this review. Before, I was happy to forget about it. Now, I can definitively say that I hate it. I hate the idea of it, I hate the experience of watching it, and I especially hate that none of this will even matter that much in the rest of the series.

“Christmas Carol” and “Emily” are so unbelievably pointless in their existence that I can’t believe nobody scratched their heads before submitting the final draft and said to themselves, “Gee, do we really want to film this?”

These two episodes also are painful reminders of one of the biggest flaws of the series: the lack of female writers. The X-Files only had a few female writers throughout the show’s run, and none on its recurring writing team. I wonder, if the script for “Christmas Carol” had been reviewed by a female writer before submission, would the episode have been made?

Hell, you don’t even need to be female to look at this and see how unbelievably messed up it all is. Scully has just recovered from cancer, for goodness’ sake. As wonderfully as the writers wrote Scully’s character, they seem to have no limitations to the amount of cruel, horrible crap this character goes through.

And right there is the very heart of why this episode and “Emily” don’t work. Scully is a strong female character thrust into an unbelievably tragic situation with no agency. Her strength is not highlighted so much as it is necessary – necessary to bear the weight of one horrible circumstance after another. Circumstances that not only limit the control she has over her life choices, but also her body. 

This can’t be blamed on Chris Carter, either. I can only assume he didn’t disapprove of the episode as it was obviously made, but it pains me to know that the trio of wonders Vince Gilligan, John Shiban, and Frank Spotnitz even conceived of this idea, let alone put a character they obviously adore through such awfulness. But I guess that’s what male writers do when they love strong female characters. Give ’em more conflict, right? Get that Emmy for Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama Series.

“Merry Christmas, Scully! We got you infertility. Love, John Gilnitz”

What makes it all worse is just how boring it turns out to be. I don’t think it’s ever taken me so long to get through an episode in one sitting. I kept turning it off and doing something else. It’s a shame, because despite all that, there was obviously a great amount of effort put into this one. Gillian Anderson is fantastic. So is Mark Snow’s score. Even the direction is nice, though in my opinion it only contributes to the overall feel of being stuck in a tank of gelatin this episode induces, at least in me.

I’ll elaborate more on all of this when I get to “Emily.” But as far as “Christmas Carol” is concerned: No. No, no, no, no, no.

And what is up with that fetus balloon?!


Final Score


Final score for “Christmas Carol” is 2/10. It feels dirty giving a Season 5 episode a score this low. But I’m sorry – nope. You know what? I’m not sorry. “Christmas Carol” deserves a 2/10, and it’s getting one.

Notable Nuggets/Nitpicks

  • There are a lot of things in this episode that warrant more than an eyebrow raise. One is the fetus balloon. The other is Mulder’s 3 second appearance. What on earth is he wearing?

Screen Shot 2016-01-03 at 4.58.28 PM

  • I don’t mind Kresge. I also don’t mind Bill Scully.
  • DNA tests take longer than an evening, don’t they? Smart science people, help me out here.
  • Yes, Gillian Anderson is flawless. The material is not.
  • What the hell? Fetus balloon?

6 thoughts on “Christmas Carol – Season 5, Ep 6

  1. Larson says:

    Although we disagree on “Never Again”, you have totally *nailed* these two episodes! I have watched TXF since the beginning and I don’t think I’ve voluntarily watched these two eps since their original airing, all for the reasons you have stated (although I don’t remember the fetus ballon, thank goodness!). In my humble opinion, the best episodes about Scully were all written by Morgan & Wong. I knew they didn’t write these two eps. You are right, a woman would never have written this either. I will continue to pretend that these two episodes do not exist. Thank you for proving I am not alone in this.

    • Knife Ink says:

      The sad thing is, Vince Gilligan’s characterization of Scully is usually great, so I was really disappointed when I found out the trio of wonders had written this one.

  2. Weird Ham Björk (@Mulder101361) says:

    These days, depending on the method, a dedicated 24-hour operating lab could probably get the results overnight, but it’s a stretch. Not too many labs have that kind of throughput and I doubt the few that do would be operating over the holiday. . Furthermore, they ran it against Melissa Scully first, then “noticed similarities”, so they presumably ran a second comparison. A 48 hour minimum isn’t impossible, assuming there are facilities accepting work over the holiday, but yes. Overnight is impossible.

Agree? Disagree? Let me know!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s